Catholic and Masturbation

Posted by Chirantha on March 3, 2007, 1 p.m.

*I only intend to show a flaw in the religion. If you feel you do not like to hear about flaws in the religion please do not read it (you have a right not to). I read the rules I didn't find anything that could stop this one. Please note that this content should not be viewed by anyone under 16. Please press the back button if you are under 16* Thanks.

*No names of the real people will be mentioned*

After some events with a person on MSN who didn't masturbate due personal and religious reasons I read up on the catholic and masturbation. It seems that the catholic religion indeed says it’s wrong to masturbate (http://www.geocities.com/Heartland/2964/masturbation2.html). However I feel that statement does not match the current time or the people.

Teenagers going through puberty have the wet dreams (but some many not have a single one at all and still be perfectly ok). Some may get these wet dreams until they die but most of the time they stop at around 17-18. This is because the body starts to control itself and stop producing sperm. Even though most religious people may consider masturbation as a *bad* act. However it seems that not masturbating is a bad act because it could lead to one destroying himself. I do not believe any religion says that a person should knowingly destroy them self’s.

According to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erotic_sexual_denial (under Long term denial) it seems modern science has proven that it is a good act and gives protection to things such as prostate cancer. I believe cancer did not exist at the time the rules of the catholic religion was made. (God has given us a brain to think use it! Don’t let God tell you what is wrong and right)

If the argument is pleasuring yourself is selfish look through your past. You could have given that tasty food plate to a hungry beggar. You could have given all your money to poor people and become a beggar but what will happen to your children? In this modern world things don't come for free. We save money for a reason. And just like that people masturbate for a reason(s) such as pleasure and protection from cancer and other prostate related problems. People like to eat testy food because it feels good to eat tasty food and people masturbate because it feels good and protects there body.

Some rules of the catholic religion is far out of date in my point of view. I know a family that got divorced because the guy couldn't have sex (a sexual dysfunction from birth), the guy didn't know it until he attempted it. If he wasn't so religious and checked if he can do it he could have explained to the girl that he can't do it and she probably wouldn't have married him. At the end the girl lost her virginity and had trouble finding another man because of our countries cultural issues.

I do believe no religion would say it’s correct to destroy a girls dream to have kids. We live to full fill our desires actually that’s all we do in life. If there was no desire in a person he would have to die.

I remember that somewhere in the bible it Jesus said to a guy "give all your belongings to the people and join me" even though it was said, no one with the right mind could do that today because there aren’t many jungles or free food to eat. If a guy gave up everything he had and joined the church he would be living off the donations and the money of other people. While he may say god gives me food to eat it is you who many be donating and feeding him. The Fathers enjoy life because they have everything they want because other people are giving the church money and all he has to do is conduct the masses -> helping some people learn religion -> eating -> sleeping. But he is a person that can use his arms and legs to earn and give money to others. Come to think of it being a father is way too much fun lol.

Comments

RhysAndrews 18 years, 11 months ago

Was that the same doctor that gave your Grandma medication that almost killed her?

Chirantha 18 years, 11 months ago

call me weird but its true. I'm sure I'm not the only one that did it at 4 or 5. there is one person that knows that I do it. As he did it at 5 or 6 as well so I really don't care about what you people think.

Chirantha 18 years, 11 months ago

btw, Rhys, I did that in my grade 5 exam :) I was 10 by then. As I said and always will say I first did when I was at preschool.

RhysAndrews 18 years, 11 months ago

An exam… maybe you were wet daydreaming. Yeah right. You suck.

-Rhys

firestormx 18 years, 11 months ago

And again, I make another fair sized comment, and more posts. >:(

Quote:
Then the problem is over doing it? Well the body will automatically make a bad feeling (pains and such) if you do it too much.
That's seriously not going to stop you if you're sexualy compulsive. Heroin addicts don't care about how bad the come-down is, they'll go right back up as soon as they can.

Quote:
We are humans! we need sex. No matter how much you deny it today you WILL have to accept that "humans need sex" one day.

If you don't understand why humans would need sex and you are over 15 then I surggest you contact a doctor O_O
That's a primitive and uneducated excuse to try and explain the phenomenon of sexual urges.

It's true that humans have the urge to have sex, and they do. Catholics aren't saying don't have sex, they're saying don't masturbate, don't have sex outside of marriage, do it for pro-creation. (I don't agree with that last one; sex is the most intimate action you can perform, and it keeps a relationship healthy)

Also, if what Rhys is saying, it sounds like masturbation is newly discovered to you, and much like who I was introduced into drugs, I didn't slowly discover it, and slowly work my way up to it, as most pubescent children do with masturbation, but instead someone's like "here's ecstatsy, ketamine, blah blah blah, have fun", and bam, I was just thrown into it, 'cause it was readily available, and I was old enough to understand a lot of what it was (but I still did it anyway, 'cause I'm dumb). I was like "wow, this is the best thing in the world, I know it's going to kill me, but I love it!", not to the point where it's like "omg! everyone should try this! you're all so ignorant!" and stuff, but I thought it wsa pretty great. Since then, I've realized - and I don't mean you'll realize this about masturbation - that it's a really bad thing, and I gotta slow down, and all that good stuff. But what I'm saying is, if this is newly discovered for you, and you're old enough to have access to the internet, to understand how to get porn, the feelings aren't new and confusing, etc, etc, of course you're going to act how you are right now. But trust me, it's not all it's cracked up to be.

"oh no, pot is safe, it's not addictive, it won't kill you, it has no side-effects, it'll be fun, you'll love it."

Pot fuckin' sucks, and it's full of problems. (btw, anyone who's reading this and smokes pot, your breasts arent' getting larger because you're eating more and getting fat, it's because pot is reducing your testosterone, increasing your estrogen, and you are literally growing boobs.)

So just, don't take it at face value. Even though I know you're not catholic or anything, I just made a huge-ass post, that went into a LITTLE BIT of how bad masturbation is for you. So be careful with it.

"But all my friends are going nuts over it!"

And how many of those friends will contract AIDs in their lifetime? Fuckin' eh to people's logic, man.

Geargod:

I didn't say a very large percentage of people were going to become sexually compulsive, but when I was listing things about sexual compulsiveness, I also stated that I had only written some of the worst stuff. There is a lot that can lead a psychistrist to believe you are SC, and recomend you go into 12 step or something.

A healthy sexual outlet is important, and catholics say that you will hopefuly get one later in life, via a wife. However, many psychologists are split on that, because a male, particularly an abuse survivor, will likely require more stimulation and a more "extreme" outlet as time progresses. Naturaly if a patient asks if they should masturbate, the doctor will likely know the patient's history well enough to usually say "go for it", or "try to keep it to a minimum".

I don't feel like repeating metaphors, but there are connections; more so than something like "watching violence will make your child agressive". Watching violence doesn't (well, shouldn't) raise your serotonin and other "happy chemicals" to such high levels.

Yes, I know all human action is for self-gratification, but like every addiction, you aren't going to like the consequences, but you will like the addiction more than the consequences, which means you're fine while you're using/doing, but once you come down/stop, and the consequences hit you, it's quite hellish. You can ask any addict who has recovered, and they will tell you they feel so much more free. It's not just because "oh, I don't rail cocain every day, and I feel great because I don't have to constantly be doing that", but it's also because now that the addiction isn't in his mind, he is able to deal with the consequences, usually sort them out, and he's able to look at life much clearer and better. Just like when you tell a huge lie, and people find holes in it, and you keep patching them up and up, and you just get deeper and deeper, and finally when you tell the truth, it's like "okay, all those consequences of people repeatidly finding holes in my stories are gone, I don't have to continually act like I was sick on that day I didn't come into work (or whatever), and sure I have to deal with this period where no one will trust me, and that'll be hell, but I'll get over it, and having people trust me again will feel great."

If it's the spouse masturbating the other person, it's considered sex. If you masturbate in the presense of your spouse - getting yourself warmed up and such - it's all good. It's like asking your wife "if I haev sex with you in your sleep, is that considered cheating?" "no" "But I thought any sex that you didn't condone was cheating" "Well, it'll be with me, so it's fine."

And cyber sex may not be cheating to you, but you're not catholic, and you simply consider an intimate act with another person to be cheating. That's how catholics think too, except that fantasizing about that (which most people have to do), is considered the same thing. You're getting the same kick out of it (yes, I know masturbation and sex with your signifigant other is always a seperate thing in a guy's head), and you're attempting to tell yourself that you're engaging in this act with someone other than your spouse.

Those relationships will fall apart, and like you, they can't see any reason why it would fall apart either. Also, I never once said the bible said so. I got this from reading up on random psychology, and talking to a few therapists I know. What generally happens, is that you are performing the most intimate act a human can engage in, with another person. You have no idea how your feelings are going to come out as, but if you go into it thinking that it's a good idea, hell that it might even spice up your relationship with your spouse, it will not do what you think at all…I really don't know how to explain this the way they do, but I've learned that it's not a good idea, you don't have to think it's a bad idea, and this is more about the "health risks" of masturbation.

Chirantha:

Quote:
firestormx, you are saying wiki is wrong. There is nothing wrong with becoming addicted to masturbation because its better than raping someone or becoming gay. People don't need porn to masturbate because urges are there.
Define what "wiki" is. Am I calling a large group of anonymous people who I have never met, and have no idea if I can trust, wrong? I actually haven't said wiki is wrong in this "conversation", but I have seen it wrong plenty of times before. That's half of why they have an edit button there.

Now then, I don't think you understand what doctors mean by addiction. You're probably thinking "oh, if you just can't stop doing it, that's addiction". That is not addiction. If that were the case, you'd be addicted to everything from breathing, to eating, to sleeping. Like I said, addiction is defined through consequences.

Also, masturbation does not discourage raping or becoming gay (no idea wtf that has to do with it), I actually said it is more likely to encourage it. Lack of masturbation will not encourage you to do those things either. Maybe you should read my post one more time?

Quote:
Also have heard of UTI's? Infections can walk into the bladder via the penis (which happened to me a lot of times because of another personal complication of mine). I'm sure a infection CAN reach the epididymis.
Urinary Tract Infection? Infection can not just "walk into the bladder". As you said, it was part of some of your personal complications. I would also like to point out that your UT leads to your bladder, steering quite clear of where semen is produced and stored. Therefore, there is nothing that masturbation could have done to "fix that".

Quote:
call me weird but its true. I'm sure I'm not the only one that did it at 4 or 5. there is one person that knows that I do it. As he did it at 5 or 6 as well so I really don't care about what you people think.
No, you're not weird. You were likely either abused, or had to find a way of self-soothing, and you turned to that. If you were abused, it will likely lead to quetions about your sexuality later in life, and if it was just self-soothing, you're just likely to become sexually compulsive. You may already be, what with the distorted reasoning you come up with to defend it. (I'm not saying it's all distorted, but there is a lot wrong with it)

Chirantha 18 years, 11 months ago

Lets say this simple.

I or anyone that does have a working reproductive system that isn't used to wet dreams can NOT stay without masturbation and sex. :-/ I am sure others can't as well. They may just say I don't but they do but they keep it secret. Which shows how needed it is.

firestormx 18 years, 11 months ago

No. You're what, 16? And you probably don't care enough about the human body to learn how it all works, but that is seriously not how it works. That's as ignorant as saying girls like vaginal sex. Very few girls like vaginal sex, and fewer still will orgasm from it. Most would prefer you go down on them, and even then, a high percentage of girls can not orgasm at all.

Or, most guys think if they play around down there, the girl will be turned on. She won't be aroused in the slightest (unless you happen to be one of those girls who can orgasm, usually they're multiple/consecutevly orgasmic), and will likely get very annoyed. You get her talking in a good and intimate conversation though, and her brain will tell her "okay, let's reproduce". Where as with a guy, you just gotta touch him, and he's like "woah! Let's goooo!"

Anyone with a functioning brain and hormones is going to become depressed at some point, and anti-depressants are going to help with that. Is everyone on anti-depressants? Should everyone be on anti-depressants? Do people have the urge to feel happier when they're depressed? Yes. Often they'll turn to alcohol or something rather than anti-depressants, but the large number of alcoholics give you a rough estimate of how many people would take anti-depressatns. (Assuming they were instant, and not some sort of treatment)

Like I said in the first post, saying "that's just how your body works" is false, and does not justify masturbation.

Maxcore 18 years, 11 months ago

hey about you get an article that cites its sources and then come talk to us.

Maxcore 18 years, 11 months ago

Also, none of you are biologists, so don't pretend to show some level of understanding on things you can't even being to understand.

Maxcore 18 years, 11 months ago

and fsx, 'the bible say so' or does not justify its poor moral standing.